Fritz, this will probably lead to you mentally masturbating over, but since you're new I'll break it down for you just for the sake of perspective.
Quote:
So something as direct as that might work?
Everything can work. That doesn't mean it will. Your "shipwreck" happened because you blatantly ignored JZ when he specifically stated that unless she's quite
interested in you to begin with, you will not get the desired outcome. And you didn't. Because she wasn't. And you could've known that.
Quote:
Something like: I go over and say, hey, I've seen you around the hallways a 1000 times, I always liked you, never met you, what's your name, what do you study bla bla and then ask her out?
No. Because:
#1. "seen you around the hallways 1000 times" - implies you're soft stalking her and have premeditated this approach for a while. Which translates to you being way waaaay too invested in what is effectively a stranger.
#2 "I always liked you" - why? What's she done to earn your liking? She was born with a vagina and cute face? that it? that all it takes to win you over?
You
don't like her. How could you? You don't even know her.
Grow some standards.
Quote:
How much conversation would I need in the bla bla section before I try to ask her out? Can I just do the introductory part about how I've seen her many times and wanted to meet her, and then maybe just 2-3 more sentences of small talk and then ask her out, or would that be too little?
And this is exactly what I mean by mental masturbation. That's what most newbies fall victim to and it's the developing an obsession over insignificant details.
This is an art form. It is not an exact science. There are no rules, there are simply guidelines.
How much conversation you need in the "bla bla section" is a stupid question.
How do I form a connection with the person I'm approaching? <- that's a smarter question.
It's also why your previous attempt failed. If you want a woman to invest the time in going out with you, she needs to be interested.
Why would she have said yes? You virtually asked her to invest time in going out with you. Why? Put yourself in her shoes and try finding a good reason to accept and you'll realize that unless she had a massive crush on you already, there is none.
So the point is, if you want a woman to accept your offer, the interaction needs to be exciting/interesting/unique or otherwise engaging enough. Any of those or a variation of those.
That being said if you decide to approach - anywhere really - during the date, you need to realize that since most dudes are cavemen when talking to women, they're naturally gonna have their guard up. So be smart and defuse the situation with something along the lines of "Hi, I know this is kinda random but I just noticed you from over there and though you were kinda cute so I wanted to introduce myself. I'm Fritz". Smile and be friendly. More importantly, be non-threatening.
From there ask what she's doing, about her classes, whatever you want. Don't make it too long because the enthusiasm dies out. From there either bounce to a coffee spot and take it from there, or ask for her number and then leave her to her work.
The goal is not getting a number or a statistic. The goal is actually meeting a hopefully cool person. Forming a connection. Having an experience. The "bla bla". That's the goal.