I agree with Pebble on the man points comment. I'm not at all a fan of negging, but in this situation you could have picked something about her pic teased her got a verbal sparring match going and built attraction that way. Another thing man don't lie if you're not doing it don't say you are. Go to
www.wayoftheplayer.com and look up the article 7 things every player needs to stop doing, but I'm not a fan of jealousy plots either. I think you should walk away from girl #1 however if you wanna give it another try I'd use the I'm divorcing you routine I've never had that not work for me get a bit of role playing going then escalate how you see fit from there.
Hope that helps good luck!!