I had an interesting conversation with a hispanic girl wearing a culinary school uniform on the train. I walked up to her and asked are you going to the Master Chef audition?

HispanicGirl: No
Me: Are you from Chicago?
HispanicGirl: No
Me: I am afraid to ask you anymore questions (smiled)
Hispanic Girl: Why?
Me: You answers are so short and non engaging
HG: You didn't even ask how I was doing, and you assumed that I from Chicago? Get to know me before getting down to business.
Me: Someone has to ask how you are doing to converse with you? Seriously, I did not assume anything> I simply asked were you from Chicago and no thank you (started to turn away).
HG: She smiles, I love it, your fresh, don't let me get away with it again. My name is Megan.
Me: Megabyte, cute

The conversation lamed up because I was genuinely shocked what I just got away with and even more shocked that she liked being told off.

Do girls like being treated like shit. Was this considered a neg. Why did she react this way? Was this a bitch shield.

She was being bitchy. You didn't take it. She liked the fact that you won't be told what to do, you're a man who doesn't suck up to her. You're different. Therefore she opened up.

Exactly women respect a man that stands up for himself even if you're standing up to her.

To be clear, this is not a neg- this is you holding your strong frame and not being thrown off by her shit test.

_________________
Preston's Game Log - Please critique

What would you say should be the right course of action once you prove that you are a "man" and will not take shit. I started being nice like I naturally am once she opened up. Should I have kept up the criticism or have been critical of her. If so, how long should I keep it up.

When a girl shows a little interest dont reward it with supplication, keep up the frame that made her interested. Really you should have number closed her after she hooked and then moved on to text/call back game. If your natural tendency is to become the "nice guy" then interaction will likely fizz out pretty quick at which case a # close will lead to nothing. Know your limitations and work around them until you fix them