Quote:
It has been almost a week since I broke up with her, and she contacted me initially the that following day and the next morning. However, she hasn't asked for another chance. I am her first boyfriend btw.
Here is some background for a better analysis:
Before the break up, she was already losing interest and told me that we weren't compatible. She would suggest to me that she wasn't very good at displaying affection, and she came to the conclusion that I was the type of guy who had to see his gf to be happy. It was difficult to see her because she doesn't drive and I'm not allowed to drive 30 mins to her house to pick her up to hang out, but we went to the same college. Anyways, she was suggesting that we could have a better friendship than a relationship, but that wasn't what I wanted. I was going through what TheGrimSweeper, which was where she was distancing herself, putting less effort into the relationship, and I felt less respected and less appreciated. I stuck around in hopes it would get better, and so that there would be no what ifs about it. Eventually, we had a talk and found out she wasn't really afraid of losing me as a boyfriend, but losing me as a best friend. I had a game plan prior that if she said that I would end the relationship. However, I believe she didn't expect me to end the relationship, because I basically blindsided her when i did it. I believe she didn't think i would have enough balls to get out of the position i was in. We seem to have ended on good terms, but I still think I want her back.
My question to you is since I ended it, but she wanted a friend anyways, is winning her back still possible?
That is going to be really tough. Your best course of action would have been to let her break up with you in that case.
Ignore the crap she says about not wanting to lose you as a best friend, that's a bunch of garbage. Women want to stay friends after breaking up because it helps them to get over the break up more quickly; they get the emotional support they need, while not having to provide anything physical. It also helps them to not feel guilty. NEVER be friends with a woman after breaking up. It helps their healing process, while hurting yours. Don't give them that benefit. If a few months or years down the road, and you're both over it, then you think you'd like to be friends, then that's fine.
In your case, it has only been a week. I would suggest you take some time, work on yourself, and try to move on. The breakup is still fresh and you are thinking about her, so you are naturally going to want her back. You might feel differently in a month.
If you do still want her back, it's going to be hard, since you broke up with her and she was pulling away anyway. You kind of did her job for her and removed her guilt. Since she wanted to be friends, you have to remove your friendship and force her to heal without your emotional support. You can still talk to her, but very Limited Contact, and you have to act calm and confident, like losing her was no big deal. Control the conversations and keep them short; be the one to end the conversations.
Do not get caught up talking about anything emotional with her. Do not be her emotional tampon. It is very important that you do NOT provide her with emotional support! Do not be there for her. You do not have to answer the phone every time she calls, or respond to all of her texts.
Is it possible to win her back? It is possible, but I think your chances are very slim. You're going to have to play this perfectly. However, I think it would be in your best interest to move on, especially considering that you were her first boyfriend. It is inevitable that she would break up with you eventually, no matter what you did. She is going to want to see what else is out there, and you need to do the same. It sounds like you are both young (late teen's, early 20's?), and I can tell you that when you reach the mid 20's, your wants, beliefs, opinions, change from year to year. If you stay together with this girl, you'll only be holding each other back from reaching your full potential.