A PUA friend told me "Go approach these girls at the bar".
Me "You recommend that I approach them? Thanks, I will think about it."
PUA: "You need to go and warm up. Come on."
Me: "How do you know what I need to warm up? I will approach them if I want, but right now I don't feel like it. Worry about yourself, and I will ask you for help if I need"
Don't push your friends to approach. Don't feed your ego through others. I've pushed shy guys to approach when they were scared to, wanted to teach guys how to approach women (even though I don't know how myself! What a delusion.), fantasized about being a dating coach, being popular with women. It's all to feeding your self esteem through others. Worry about yourself. Ever catch yourself thinking, if I.... people would like and respect me and I'd feel great. Well you won't. If you are not feeling perfectly happy right now where you are, you will still feel lousy if that fantasy comes true. That longing to feel better through impressing others drives minimum wage guys to take out loans on BMWs, buy expensive lunches for first dates who don't appreciate them, and fantasize about becoming PUAs. Think of a time when people were impressed with you and you did not feel better regardless of what they thought. Don't try to make yourself feel more dominant and powerful by teaching others how to attract women or pushing your PUA friends to approach. Ask them to point to who you should approach for a change. I never seen any PUA do that. Oh no, it's too vulnerable for them. You feel more secure when you teach others and push them to improve. So when you have an earge to give someone a push, ask them to give you a push instead. When you have an urge to teach someone, tell them something you would like to learn. Like say - dancing. How many PUAs are afraid of dancing!
And how many desperate guys pay $10-20/hr to take group dancing lessons. My friend took ballroom dancing lessons for three years ($4000), did yoga in the mornings on a video tape (free). Now he still does not know how to move to music even at family birthday parties, after all that instruction and practice. He says, group dancing lessons, are not conductive to learning. I tried a hip hop class myself for $10, and did not learn any physical moves (but the psychological practice of moving to music in a group was good for me.) Guys will take salsa lessons, but there should be a better way. After all, we are not studying to have perfect technique to win a ballroom dancing competition, we want to learn a few moves and practice moving on our own or with a partner to jazz, rock, hip hop, whatever happens to be played. My solution would be to download some Zumba and Dance for Pick Up videos from the Internet and Basic Dancing DVDs at the library and do that for a couple of months at home. I never tried this, but then you could use that at the bar (if you are still chasing bar girls, I hope you are not!

), but that could be a day two. Tell a girl you've been learning to dance at home and now you are going to take a class alone, and if she wants to come by, you'd love to see her. And just giver her the time and address where you are going to take the dancing lesson and don't exchange numbers. That probably won't work, it somehow feels too desperate. But anyway, the guy who did yoga at home for free and spent $4000 on ballroom dancing, well now, he still can't dance at a party and does not have a dancing partner. So all that money on dancing was not a good investment. But the free yoga at home was! He started doing martial arts, and even though he is middle aged, he is more flexible than the twenty year olds there.
I logged in today to see if I got more comments on this thread. And I was happy to see there was one more. I was looking for attention online. There's plenty of lonely people like me mostly in forums and dating sites, sitting down at the computer hoping to make themselves feel better when someone "Likes" their status update on Facebook, if that 50th woman you messaged on a dating site replied, who viewed your dating profile, who answered or quoted you post at the forum. What I am doing right now (hoping that people will like and appreciate my thread) is called People Pleasing Behavior. If nobody noticed my thread, I'd feel bad. If people think it's great and post comments, I am happy. There's a post about in on the No More Mr Nice Guy Forum. Apparently that's what nice/desperate/low self esteem guys do - try to please others and worry what other's think about them, even online. Here's the post:
Quote:
Seeking approval in the digital age
It has occurred to me just how much Facebook can contribute to approval seeking behaviors. When I post something to my wall (usually a quote) I check it repeatedly to see who "likes" it.
I've also caught myself picking quotes or editing things for "maximum approval" instead of putting up there what I really want to say (appropriate things of course).
Goal for the next week: Whenever I post something, I can't log on again until the next time I am going to post something. I also will post without regard to what others will think about it but post something that speaks TO ME.
Seeking approval is a hard thing to get over.
I found old classmates and a teacher I was very close to on Facebook. Success. I tried asking girls out over facebook. Fail. I tried befriending classmates in college over facebook chat and sending messages back and forth. Fail. I tried compensating for the uncool lifestyle I seem to have had in college compared to other kids who have a 1000 party pictures uploaded and as many facebook friends, and it's not worth effort. Facebook is good for finding people and organizing events. So I'm not going to log in to look at other people's photos, read other people's updates, their work/school/relationship info, or post updates of my own. I'm going to log in to follow up on the birthday party my friend is organizing, but that's it. Even as I am writing I am thinking, "Anyone who reads this will think I am a lonely socially isolated person. I better mention that I am invited to a birthday party by a friend via facebook to make myself look better."
Another good post on that Nice Guy thread:
Quote:
Overall I agree Facebook is a swarm of approval seeking behavior gone to the extreme. Its instant gratification and validation.. or ridicule, depending on what is put up and how addicted you are to responses you receive, it can make you feel good or shitty, which goes to show, you can let facebook control you and your emotional state
It's also unnecessary self torture to stare at pictures of people having fun when you are on your computer, alone. That's only going to make you feel worse. Turn the computer off, or take a 30 minute break, go on Google Video and search for "Basic Yoga." Now that will instantly make you feel better.
Why look for attention and appreciation on the forums, when you can pay attention and appreciate yourself. Cook a meal for yourself. Clean your room. Set a nice white table cloth and have a traditional English Solitary Tea. If you are still in college, why not look at an essay that has already been graded, and rewrite it and give yourself a grade. Why not read an interesting book. Why not do some basic yoga to stretch and feel better, so that in a couple of years you too are flexible enough to learn martial arts, dancing, or parkour. If you don't have any hobbies, but you like movies, read some movie reviews and take notes on movies you want to rent. It's all easier said than done. Many of us including myself fall into a depression and procrastination and find ourselves spending hours in a trance at the computer. But one way to slowly get out of that is to keep a list of things you have done during the day. It might realistically take you a couple of months to start keeping this list regularly, but for now just do this once. Write a list of things you did today. Here is my list:
Wrote a forum thread post
Listened to This American Life podcast
Washed/Dried a bag of laundry
Finished a fiction book
Brushed my teeth
Checked my email
Emailed a craigslist seller back about a $25 framed picture
I used to keep TO DO lists, but writing down what I have actually done, even little things, is the only thing that ever helped me break out of procrastination. That's all in the Feeling Good book by Dr. Burns.
I've been on different forums for years, and if I reply to posts, people fade away. Whereas, if I ignore what others have posted, the posts keep coming. I theorize that when you see that the Original Poster does not reply to people, it makes you hungrier for attention. I imagine that's how women think of guys. The whole ignoring your target concept. But fake ignoring a target is like faking confidence. I've been reread The Game by Neil Strauss, wondering which parts are exaggerated, and which are true to what I have seen during my brief stint in the PUA community. There's parts in it about how a virgin had sex with an asian girl he picked up and was disappointed how it was not pleasurable like he imagined and even hurt. About how guys who have been marginalized in middle school and high school, now were trying to act more alpha male and ended up acting to their PUA friends like their former school bullies.
I am not an alpha male, and I more of a feminine, mild tempered, guy. I can try to hide it by putting up a facade - joining the army, taking up MMA, getting into fights, getting tattooed, getting a motorcycle, drinking like a man. In fact, the guys in the army who advance through the ranks, are in touch with their feelings because that is how they understand others and can lead. But I am trying to embrace my non-alpha male qualities, and I am hoping that might make me more masculine. Think of the rock stars from the eighties - they grew out long hair, like women, didn't they? If you embrace your non-alpha qualities it's better than if you try to be fake alpha. You won't be happy unless you find self acceptance, and women will see through you anyway. I don't like action movies. I could try to hide it, but that would make me less attractive. Or I could be open and ok about it, and talk about how I like independent films.
Ok, so women like alpha males? So we all start pumping ourselves up and faking confidence? Hmm.. There's an interview with a founding father of Pick Up in The Game.
What is the existential despair?
We're social beings, so we all struggle
with a sense of inadequacy. But when we realize that we're not as inadequate
as we thought we are, and when we see that everybody else also thinks they're inadequate,
then that pain goes away and the idea that we're not a person of value disappears somewhat.
So feeling inadequate just means you are human, it might never go away, and if you are open about it with
the right people (not everyone), then it's a way for you to connect with that person. Just like you can easily connect
with another person (again not anyone) over depression, grief, or any other negative feeling. That's why the PUA community
can be theraputic because you can find other guys who feel inadequate, or who also feel fear, anxiety, rejection when they
approach women or go on dates or hurt after their girl friend broke up with them (which is how many get into pick up in
the first place.)
And what about people who don't solve their feelings of inadequacy?
They become obsessed with having sex with more and more women. And
that's a problem.[Because unless you very secure about yourself, you will feel bad when that woman ignores your calls
or sleeps with other guys]
It's OK to say NO to woman. Men complain that they feel used after having sex with an aggressive woman. And women won't take NO for an answer. Even if the guys does not feel comfortable with sex, they will keep pushing for it. It's OK to say NO. You can be out on a first date and kiss the woman's neck and hug her and touch hands, but say you won't kiss her. She might says, "well then you can't touch my boobs unless you go through the stages." You might be at a girl's place and make out and just sleep together with her but say you won't have penetration sex. The girl might keep trying and then give up on you after you reject her several times. She might not call you back for a second date, but then she probably would not have a relationship with you anyway. You can't worry about what she thinks of you if you say NO to sex or kissing or whatever. If you give in, you will be taken advantage of and feel guilty afterward. If you say NO, you will discover that many women will be OK with it and your relationship with them won't be affected. It will probably make things easier for them, because if they have sex with you and you did not want to have sex, they will feel confused. Whereas if you are clear and assertive about your feelings, you might feel less worry and more pleasure! Now the opposite, telling the woman you want to have sex with her, that's much harder. You can start by telling a woman you feel attracted to, just that. But without any implications. Not a stranger, but if you have a female friend, it does not matter whether she is single or not, if you feel attracted to her, you can mention it and see how she feels about you saying it. She might have multiple feelings at the same time, she might feel awkward, happy, uneasy, threatened, guilty, etc.
I was at a bar invaded by guys doing PUA. They were early twenties and some in their forties. A few two sets and a closed circle of girls on their night out. Now I watched these women get hit on by different guys. Initially, the women are surprised and entertained by the guy, and they are nice/polite back (unless he gets blow out right away), but then they wait for the guy to leave. Some women bite, and end up talking to the guy for an hour and look at him like they want to have sex with him. But to me, the guys' insecurities were clear as day, and the harder they tried, the more desperate they looked. I was happy that I was not doing that anymore. I thought about approaching, but my approach anxiety kicked in, this time I worried that I'd be acting like a desperate guy if I approached. That "Must Please" mentality is still there. But approaching women at bars.. I don't know. People go to bars to look for fun, not because they are happy and want to share that happiness with others. I might still go to bars and approach women to experiment, but I still have the desperate hope to be liked by bar girls. To approach women because I have an interesting personality and am curious about other people and want to have and want to share my happiness with others..
To sum things up, right now I am still learning to cook at home and not eat out, keep the apartment clean, set a nice table for myself when I eat, read books, stop procrastinating with studying, bills, finishing decorating my walls, still need to get a desk for my electronics hobby and tools, set up a dental and a medical appointment, start writing down how much I spend (so I can be more responsible financially), make a budget for the next month. Mainly, I am struggling with cleaning and cooking and organizing and not procrastinating. And exercise, I want to do yoga and Zumba at home. It's the CBT trio where you change your Thoughts, Feeling, and Behavior, and all three together create a cycle of positive change in your life, and it's the behavior part that I need to put more effort in.
Ego Strength
Most guys don't have enough ego strength to go to strip club alone, that's why they go with friends, for security. Well, there's other reasons too, I'm exaggerating to make a point. Most people don't have the ego strength to go to a bar and sit or even better stand alone. But I have a shitload of ego strength not only can I go and stand at a bar alone, but I can also decide that I am going to be a freerider and not buy anything. The waitress might keep coming up to me and asking me if I want anything, and the bouncer might politely ask if I am feeling ok. Once I went into a bar and was like "Shit, what do I do? I need a beer." Once I had it in my hand, I was relieved that the spotlight was off me and I blend in. While going to a bar or night club and standing alone and not drinking is weird, I think it's a good think to practice to get over the psychological mental distortions and worries. Don't do it all the time (although why not?), do it a couple of times and pay attention to the thoughts and feelings that go through your head. Sometimes I go out, and get a beer, but I think that's not a good habit to feed. So I'm going to get one beer and just nurse it over like an hour or two and then leave.
Ever since I got into pick up a couple of months ago, and even after I kind of quit pick up, I have not gotten any results with women yet. I did group therapy with a very talented old therapist and now I can talk to people more assertively and am much more open about my feelings (when I want to be). Looking back, the experiences with women I've had before getting into pick up were accidental when I was out at a theater show, concert, party, bar, etc. So my goal will be to just talk to more women without trying to attract them or worry about winning them, and to be out more in public. So I am trying to have it both ways - to both be happier when I am alone, and to be out more and talk to more women.
Dr. Burns recommends planning out potentially productive and pleasurable activities hour by hour so that you don't have a free moment to sit and feel miserable and sorry for yourself. So let me try to put this in action.
0730am - shower
0800 - have breakfast at a coffee shop
0900 - have breakfast at a coffee shop, buy a used book to read for fun
1000 - vacuum, organize clothes
1100am - wash dishes, make soup
1200 - call setup appointments
1pm - have lunch, cook food at home, work in basement
2pm - call parents and family
3pm - read book
4pm - set up elaborate dinner
5pm - clean refrigerator
6pm - give myself a hair cut, go grocery shopping for the next two days (don't overshop)
7pm - set up a hobby work station
8pm - do basic yoga at home
9pm - go to sleep early
I'm going to write this in Dr. Burns's Pleasure Predicting Log. I've also started a list of things I like about myself.
So Step 1 in Dr. Burns's book to overcome the psychology of loneliness is to be happy when you are alone and treat yourself like a good room mate and partner. Step 2 is to approach people.
PUAs skip step one, and go right to step 2. Dr. Burns's says it's really important to learn to be happy as a clam when you are alone, before you are ready to build relationships with others, otherwise he says you will simply defeat yourself.