Quote:
Ever tried. Ever failed. No matter. Try Again. Fail again. Fail better. --Samuel Beckett
Nothing like a barely relevant quote from someone else...
The problem with PUA isn't what it teaches, it's who it's being taught to. Who is it most appealing to? When you look around the forum, who's asking and who's answering? What's being asked?
I gotta be honest, PUA seems genuinely appealing to kids and douchebags. And when they get together and learn something, boy or boy are they too stupid to learn from it...
PUA is summed up as social skills, confidence. I read a few books, heard a few tapes, I have absolutely no need or desire to go to the bootcamp thing, I'm fine. I think the whole thing could be summed up as social skills, and confidence.
But if you don't see the big picture, if you don't try to understand why things work, and instead just try and understand how, you end up not understanding anything.
It does say to not care about other people's opinions of you, and it does say to have this immaculate confidence so it can dribble out into how you act. If a group of people don't care to know WHY you do that, you end up with a group of cocky jackasses or idiots looking like a walking Hot Topic with their attempts at peacocking. I have to be honest, I think Mystery looks pretty stupid in most of the things he wears. But that's him, it works for him, he likes it, it's cool. I wouldn't wear it.
I see all these threads on here asking about their high school relationships, and all these threads asking if their clothing is peacock-ish enough...PUA isn't a problem, it's who's learning it and how.
I for instance wasn't interested in PUA specifically, I liked evolutionary psychology first (psych in general is interesting to me) and I found this. An important key in psychology is "why".
I'm pretty sure this isn't how most people found PUA, I'm going to guess guys who can't get laid, get so desperate to get laid, they find PUA as a means to get laid. And that is a group of people who don't care "why" anything works. And that means that group doesn't understand PUA, and that leads to the idiots who take things to an extreme because they can't observe why things work or don't work, so they ask specific questions as to HOW to get things to work.
PUA would be beneficial if it appealed to the right audience.
Side notes on a few specific posts...not giving a fuck about what anyone thinks of you can easily be the mindset of a murderer or rapist (after all, why should they care? If they can avoid consequences, they shouldn't care). I don't think that not caring what everyone thinks about you is a goal. I think it's good to keep you being you, but if you stink, and have nasty breath and look like crap, and you don't care...that's fine, let's just hope you don't care if anyone gets near you or not.
And common sense is common, it's in the name. If it's not common, it's not common sense. But since some people don't learn why, there's nothing they can apply common sense to...after all, they only know how, not why.