It seems to me, with this limited information, you made one of the most fundamental AFC mistakes. You basically pissed away all your value by putting her above you.
Quote:
right off the bat she said she was very attracted to me and I told her I was interested in her as well.
Why do you feel the need to reciprocate her compliment or declare you unqualified interest? This is generically a bad idea, if you want to pay her a sincere compliment dont tie it to her statements about you, it comes off as inherently low value. Telling a girl you are attracted to her without making her compliant first is a ham-fisted bumble. Is this a pattern? I would guess that you are a good looking guy who gets friend zoned a lot because you feel the need to supplicate, facilitate, and appease.
Quote:
I was constantly making her laugh, we were really enjoying each others company
Are you providing comfort and rapport instead of pumping attraction? Making a girl laugh is a good opening move, its generally counterproductive in excess on a date.
Quote:
she really enjoyed hanging out with me and that it almost felt like she was hanging out with herself.
A girl should never get that feeling from a successful date.
Remember girls are looking for a guy who is above them on the social ladder, climbing down to meet her at her level or beneath it is always a back-patting, friendly smiles, death sentence for attraction.
This physical escalate thing is generally a red herring compared to the real issue.