I'll keep this brief. First, I historically never have been a fan of it, and either I am doing something wrong or I am reminding myself why, I always feel it to be unnatural.
First, I'm 38, divorced, no kids and keep active and I'm in fairly good shape. I first tried on-line dating when I first got divorced, because I had really no idea what to do, and it was good to bang out the first few chicks, I then noticed I really didn't like any of the girls I was meeting, and, as I started getting back into the game, I was doing much better in the quality department on my own, the old fashion way.
I did end up with a serious gf, there was complications there not worth getting into, so now I've been single again. After I broke up with my gf, I was doing my thing again, the natural way, and doing well, but then also felt I didn't like the women I was meeting ultimately. The best thing that came out from this gf was I found out what I want and what I do like and not, basically, I wanted to eventually have another serious relationship, and the girls I was now meeting were crazy slut bags, which we know are good and bad for obvious reasons. So, I thought I'd give the on-line match thing another chance.
Started out the same, banged out a few hotties, then started taking it more serious....looking for something more meaningful. Now, I meet a ton of chicks, but none of them go anywhere, or don't last long. I've even had girls tell me, "wow, you're like the only normal, cute guy I have ever met on-line." then I never hear from them ever again.
Which brings me to this one...DEFINITELY more plain jane than I have gone out with in a long time. I even took her out to meet my friends, watch some football, talk fantasy, she's actually really into this stuff. My friends, all really liked her and thought I should pursue, while I a little reluctant, I started thinking the same, and actually, even if I got friend zoned with this chick, I think I'd be okay with it. I don't know too many 31 year old women into cool, guy stuff...she also runs like me, etc. We definitely have stuff to talk about it. If I had to compare her to my ex, who was my age, my last girlfriend was like an 8, 8.5, this one is like a 6, and I'm giving her a six because she has a runner ass...most of you might even say 5.
We've been texting, like I said she likes football, and is even into the show The League. When I asked her to get dinner later the week, she did go silent, then we started talking about other stuff, then I even said to her, I'm wondering if you're too good to be true.

She then responded, I'm just me, unfortunately I'm not sure my feelings for you are as strong. I simply wrote back after awhile, just you is fine. I'm just trying to get to know you better - which, actually is true.
So, here's my thing...how is it, on my own, I am getting smoking hot chicks to be into me, but when I meet these girls on-line, match or whatever, that are like 5,6s I'm having issues? Not to be an ass, but I kind of think I am out of her league.
Any thoughts? Much appreciated.
j.