Quote:
You're just settling with what you have on your plate. Even though you have a few girls, the 5 has more traits that you like so you are fixating on her. But just realize that you are only doing that because you have limited options and this girl is the overall most appealing one.
I was dating a 6 a while back and she acted like she was a 9. I eventually started to resent her, and I realized that I was more attracted to other girls. She had a lot going for her, but I exited that relationship and moved on to greener pastures. If you accept it for what it is and move on and stay positive I guarantee you can do better and you'll be happier. There's nothing wrong with milking it for a while, but don't get too caught up with her.
What should I do now? she just suddenly stopped returning my call/text, which makes me want her even more

... talking to the other 2 girls and ignoring her doesn't work at all.... I just cant stop thinking about this average looking girl even when I am sitting on the table having dinner with an 8......