This isn't meant to put down any guys who wear make up, just an opener I thought of outside of Starbucks today while eating some Subway and it worked on a HB8 inside. Inspired by a man next to my car in the parking lot applying full women's make-up.

PUA: Can I ask you a question?
HB: Yes
PUA: Do you think its weird when a guy likes to wear full women's make-up?
HB: What? Why do you?
PUA: Of coarse not. Why does it look like I do? (Point to no make up face) But earlier I was enjoying a sandwich in my car when I noticed a man applying eye-liner. At first I thought nothing of it but then I saw him start putting on make-up and blush, blah blah blah.

It is also good setup for a potential neg. about her make up. Like he was putting entirely too much on, kind of like you...