Alright, so I'm a teen playing teen game (Really? No shit!). Here's my problem. I can open fine, and I usually transition nicely, but I've been getting a lot of the same response that I can't think of a whitty thing to! Here it is:

Me: You seem pretty smart, what school do you go to?

Her: XXX School

Me: Oh God, I've heard of you XXX girls!

Her: Hahaha, like what?


What do I say to that?! I'm trying to keep cocky-funny, but I just can't think of something to say. Thanks in advance!

You could just maintain eye contact with a slight smile giving her a knowing look. She might try to guess what you are talking about. Don't over think these things though, it really isn't worth it. Especially for small witty responses, a small response isn't going to instantly make her get into your bed. Just have fun with it but don't kick yourself over the little things, really I learnt that the hard way.

Id play the whole...you dont know the stories?

Surely being one of (xxx)'s finest you should at least know what uve let urself in for...

_________________
Cocky/funny is the way to go....and a good/unique opener

once you have drawn her attention with that, pull the "eh, nevermind you dont wanna here it (while briefly touching her arm)" it will drive her nuts and make things easy for escalation, but eventually your gonna have to give her something to work with, make up some random funny/absurd fact about girls from her school.

For example if at a bar "Well, i heard ~insert school~ girls cant handle there alcohol" then transition to 5 lies game

if not around alcohol, "Well, i heard ~insert school~ girls are high maintanance" this will make her qualify herself and you can tease her along the way

_________________
FAIL PROOF PICK UP LINE: excuse my, im sorry to bother you but my father beats me, can i have your number.