Right. So i had sex for the first time last night and it was great, though we didn't use a condom (i know, i know, rookie mistake and i'm paying for it now). Problem is i pulled out once and my penis was very oily and it smelled of semen. Felt thicker than her vagina lube and i was wondering if it is possible to have came without me noticing. Had no orgasm but i did notice a drop of precum as well.

Question is, does a woman's natural lube smell like that or am i fucked ? Also, is it possible to come without noticing when you're very horny ?

pre-cum usually has a very low sperm content. Yes it is possible to cum a little and not notice. The chances that she is pregnant and you didn't consciously orgasm are pretty low but not non-existeant. That whole smell test thing means nothing, you can never know a girls Ph and other vaginal fluid composition and make assumptions.

I would just check in with her until you know she has had her period.

I dont want to scary you. but this is playing dumb. Never heard of diseases?

You have really low probability she is pregnant, probably the smell was her fluids.

BUT nobody here can tell you if she is pregnant or not. If she was ovulating, if you did came and didnt notice.

I would tell her to take the pill. Seriously. like detox told you "retty low but not non-existeant" so it means, she can be pregnant. A baby can ruin your life on the wrong time of your life.

And be smart next time. Would check dst, if you dont know the girl so well.

_________________
Oh! You've gotta be kidding me!

You are fucked.

Na just want to scare you. But serious, if it is not already over 24 hours later you should go with her and take the "morning after pill".

It is possible to come a little without noticing. Also I agree to Snake Doctor: "Never heard of diseases?".

Go with her to the doctor (I do not know how it is handled in your country with this) and let her take the "Morning after pill" if not more than 24 hours have passed since then. You can then wait till her next period or you let her do a pregnancy test in 2-3 weeks, if her period did not come yet then, to be sure.

The probability for her to get pregnant is not very hight but still exist. Wish you good luck in this and hope that you learn something out of this for the future. Never fuck without condom, except it is your girlfriend and you two prevent pregnancy with other usual methods.