@Streetlight
Quote:
she went away but I felt I won this argument
Does it really matter that you won? The real win is getting the girl anyway.
Ok, as for a rejoinder, yeah, the mehow idea is a good one. Another possibility is just teasing her for thinking immediately of Mystery.
Possible answers:
"What, do I look like I'm wearing goggles and a hat?"
*Ignore*
"Oh, it's terrible how he's affecting our minds now, isn't it? Every idiot in a club thinks he can get a girl 'cuz he can ask who lies more..." (Completely change topic)
Anyway, a better solution is to make up your own openers. Then you don't necessarily get called out on it. The girls don't mind if you're a player, they mind if you're an unoriginal player.