Something I came up with today discussing the topic with my friend.

PUA:Quick question for you guys, would you ever date someone you have never met before, like online or a blind date
Her: Possibly.
PUA: Alright, now to the real question, would you marry someone that you have never met before?
Her. Whatever.... Why do you ask?
PUA: See my friend is interested in this guy she has never met. Her parents found and met the guy and they have been talking on the phone. He asked her to move to Dubai with him and get married. How would you deal with this situation?
Her....


Edit:
Or another is

Which city does Superman protect? I was just having a debate with my friends. He thinks its New York I say metropolis, which is it.

Another:
Would you rather go out on a date with Mr. Bean, Borat or Chandler?

Any tips or suggestions would be great. I hate using the typical openers since those are not really questions that I like to ask.

good openers... thats what they're supposed to look like... quick, not demonstrating interest, and demonstrating value. i like the first one though. just make sure you can transition from them.