There might not be anything wrong with you.....she's just clever. She can obviously read body language and you might have met your match? Have you given her a reason to doubt you. It might be harder to get through to her.
I like RitchyRich's suggestion of being lighthearted/sarchastic.
"Another way you can say it is "I don't know WHAT your talking about, I'm actually TERRIBLE with women" with a smile. Here your being sarcastic and it will lighten the mood. I heard MANY times women like it when you poke fun at yourself, but are still confident. It shows you dont take yourself so seriously."
I think you're on to something there Ritchy
If I liked the guy, this would make me laugh. For me that's like you're kind of admitting but it making a joke of it. If I didn't really like him I'd probably say "Yeah right!"
BUT, be prepared for her response becuase she might reply "Then why are you trying with me? Are you trying to say I'm easy!!?" ;p If you were speechless or a bit embarrassed after that I would think you were cute and I'd give you more of my time.
Depending on the woman this could really backfire and she might acutally think this for real :/
Undiscovered's one would be the one to use as a last resort I think.
"now you've totally made this conversation awkward is this how it's always going to be like with you?"
Make sure that you'd say this in a very light-hearted otherwise the conversation will be REALLY awkward lol!!
Not sure about yours Premier :/
""I know, girls have been staring at me all day"
"Wow you're good, you could tell even if i weren't even hitting on you"
"Oh you heard gossip about me haven't you"
I would NOT be impressed at all with Barney Stinson's negs...sorry...let me explain why.
"You think I'm hitting on you?" > I would think in my head "You and I both know you're hitting on me....so don't be such a coward and try and make it out like it's in my imagination". It's like saying 'God this girl actually thinks I'm hitting on her. How silly of her!"
"Yea, that girl over there keeps eye fucking me." > OMG don't say this!!!! I would say ''Good for you!''
"Can you imagine how impressed you'd be if I was trying."
Ican understand how this would work if she was really comfortable with you. But inside my head I'd be thinking "God this guy has no idea". I would find it embarrassing, and if my guard was already up and if I smelled the whiff of a sleezy man my response would be
"You are trying...and guess what? I'm not impressed. You obviously think you have a golden cock....so go stick it in the mouth of someone who will flatter your ego more than I will".
Sounds harsh, but if my guard is up, that would be my defensive response. I would probably have walked away by that point :/