At 16-17, a stuff toy is fine. But the best gift ever, especially to a girl who is definitely starting to get romantically interested in guys is to give her soaps or such.Bath and Body Works usually have some super cheap options (perfect if you don't have a job or hardly know her), and or about $10, you can get 3 bottles of soap. Anchor them to you, and she'll be thinking about you every time she's washing herself. Imagine, as her soapy hands are rubbing slowly over her breasts, she's thinking "Oh, yeah, Drayzie gave me this". Powerful stuff!
If you want extra points, remember what the scent of the soap is, and when she's wearing it around you, mention that you like it.
