Quote:
I'm not terrible at pick-up. It's just that doing it requires a 180 degree change from my current self to create attraction. I'm pretty quiet and introverted. You'd usually find me at the bar sitting alone unless I've kicked myself in the ass to do otherwise.
Sarging requires me to wind myself up and power forward opening set after set hoping to get a few numbers and a girl interested enough in being seduced before I crash. It's a real challange, but things could be worse I guess.
Reading this, makes me realize one of the reasons I end up arguing with people (like BlondGuy) who keep saying "be direct!" Some of us are extroverts, others of us are introverts. I'm not sure that "you have to be an extrovert" is a beneficial statement. The Myers Briggs Type Indicator is one classification system that tells us that people have different psychological types. The MBTI doesn't impose value judgments on whether being an extrovert or an introvert is "better," it is simply a system for classifying people's differences. "Falsifying Type," where you feel you have to be fundamentally different from what you actually are, is a recognized medical problem in some circles, with real physiological effects. Over time you can actually damage your brain. A naturally extrovert PUA may gravitate towards "Be Direct!" and exhort everyone that they should learn game just like theirs. But for an introvert, indirect game might actually be more appropriate. I just have a hard time telling an introvert that what's "wrong with them" is they're not enough of a hard charging crowd working car salesman.
I don't have any problem telling guys, including myself, that they've got incorrect internal attitudes, assumptions, and "rules" about how they can / can't / should / shouldn't interact with women. Maybe that's why some people in the "direct" crowd get annoyed, fed up with, and "call bunk on" internal game. They don't believe in it because they're extroverts and external actions are what matter to them.
Of course you do have to talk to the gal sometime. But on what attitude, mindset, and terms? Practice is definitely part of the way to get better, but I know that just throwing yourself at it isn't enough. That's all I did when I was younger, just throwing myself at it by brute force, despite my introvert nature. I didn't know any PUA. Yes I got "better" but all I really managed to be was a slightly more successful AFC. It did a lot of damage to me and created a lot of bad internal attitudes.
I see this all as a process of finding your voice and your power. That means at some point you have to own it. If you deeply sense that something is bullshit, or at least "bullshit for you," you need to trust those feelings and act on them.