You took some time to type this out... take some time to read this thread...
my-opinion-on-looks-and-how-it-effects- ... 57229.html
^hmm, some posts are deleted or missing (or maybe I'm just tired from finals)... but anyway what Madals says on the second page is gold.
Summary: Looks matter, you can still attract women.
[sidenote] I didn't hit puberty till after high school, don't sweat it man. And when I did the girls from my high school pursued me for the first year (an anomaly really... I had the opposite experience of you -- looked like a 15-18 year old teenager till i was 23ish)... now that I look masculine (enough heh) I'm working on my game, I'm not going to wait around.