That would be a very odd thing to say for a girl.
If a girl did say that, however, I'd know from my social calibration that I have an opportunity to be as equally "creepy" as her statement "Where have you been all my life?"
My immediate response was "Admiring you from afar, of course

"
IMO it's a lot more important to SOI than to neg. Giving a Statement of Intent communicates more assertive masculine energy that will attract the passive feminine. You should only use negs to calibrate SOIs that went a little too far. Yes, I use microcalibration even though people say I teach "natural game," whatever the hell "natural game" means.
And, if a girl says something that would normally be classified as "creepy" because it shows too much interest out of context, you should definitely match her state of interest as soon as you can so that she doesn't feel that unmatched-interest vibe. If a girl feels that interest levels are not similar in an interaction, something is "creepy." If you don't match her own damn creepiness she might end up justifying her feeling of unmatched interest as you being creepy!