It seems as if you have her attracted, but attraction is nothing without a real connection. How many deeper more meaningful conversations do you have with this girl? Do you actually know her or do you just like that she laughs at your jokes? I think "playing the jealousy card" if you put it that way is like planning on doing something cruel to someone else. There is nothing wrong with talking to other girls, but to plot plans of action so that one will like you and play games like that I feel is immature and needy. I think you have a chance with this girl, but you must find out who she really is, and she must want to find more of who you really are. As far as you thinking that you can't talk to her if you sit with the other girls. I don't understand. Why can't you talk to all 3 of them? To answer your question simply. First step find out who she actually is and if you like it, second and I know some people on here would disagree with me, but if you decide you really like her you must put your balls on the line and go for it. I personally feel that the men that don't even finish the job and at least try to get what they want will always regret it. If you get rejected at that point then so be it. A real man's love spreads to all women not just one, so a rejection is really just nature saying hey redirect your focus over here and look at all the other amazing women I have to offer. Life is bliss.
_________________
You have balls yes, but how often do you actually use them?
Self help.. that's mental masterbation. Self Destruction.. now we're getting somewhere!
"
http://www.confidencedynamics.com"- science backed confidence coaching