Quick rundown:
HB1 is a girl I've been talking to for a month now and I've yet to close her. I'm starting to get frustrated with her but at the same time a lot of my issues are just poor timing not a lack of intrust.
HB2 Is a close friend of HB1 who I met last night. She is a freaking knockout and I'm super into her! We hit it off big time and if it weren't for the fact HB1 invited me out I would have closed her. But non the less I did get a number close and she invited me to a club in little rock tomorrow.
HB3 is a girl I met a few months ago ended up not closing her that night then met her again last week and she drove me home after I got drunk. I got her inside my place but due to my roommate dating her best friend the slut shield went up. But we've been talking all week and she wants to go to a different night club in little rock this weekend too since she is off work.

So here is the twist. I just got a text from HB1 saying she is going now too. So I have three girls wanting me to take them out on the same night and two are best friends... and I've already committed!

What do I do?

HB2 sounds like the one for you. You've already closed and her interest is high. HB3 would be my second choice simply because her driving can make logistics easier.

HB1 sounds like a little bit of oneitis, considering you're stopping yourself from hitting on other girls because you're afraid to lose her.

Very true. The problem is that if I try and hookup with HB2, HB1 will be there to witness. And that may just fuck me out of both.

I may could postpone HB3 till Saturday night. But should I even go with both other girls?

One thing I'll throw into this... both HB1 and HB2 are bi and I had them making out with cherries for me. (I'd hold a cherry in my mother one would kiss it from me then they would make out and one would get the stem, then tie it into a knot! Was freaking Hottt!) So there could be a slim possibility of a 3some. But I don't think they've ever had a guy together so I'm not putting money on that.

Hell yea try for the threesome. At best you get it, and at worst at least you gave it a shot. Don't be looking back 5 years later regretting a missed chance.

I've had 2 friends interested in me before, but I only wanted 1 of them. They brought me down into the basement of my friends house and turned off the lights. I was afraid that if I turned down one of them, the other would leave also. My fears were disproved when the other girl stayed after I rejected her friend, looking at me with puppy dog eyes just waiting for me to kiss her.

There's no reason you can't be interested in both girls, and it will only be a problem if you make it one. Don't apologize for your masculine sexuality.

If HB3 can be rescheduled, then go with HB1 and 2. See where the night takes you, try for a threesome. If that doesn't work out, then go after the one that is clearly more interested. If HB1 walks away and HB2 has her hand on your thigh, GO FOR HB2.

Personally I've never had a threesome, so I can't give you specific advice, but just google some threesome lay reports and see if you can get some tips from there.

If i were you this is what i'd do. i've done this before before my current AFC stint so i dunno how well this might work for you:

start early, bag the easiest one first. once you're done, pretend to get a phone call from a friend and discuss how they are in the hospital and ho you have to be there asap. then get out to town and meet up your number two.

HB 3 u keep for saturday night so ur set

as for 1 and 2...live for the stories!!!!!!!! try and get them both at your place and do the induction massage routine (you say you heard of a great massage where two people massage you simultaneously and it feels like a thousand hands are massaging you since both people are doing the same movements. then you switch people while slowly escalating the hotness)

if you fuck it up you have one hell of a story and if you get it.....

either way you have a HB for saturday and a great story.

Yeah I know that routine... I actually halfass tried it in the club last night so in privacy it may work. The trouble is going to be getting them back to mine together, then I gotta keep my roommate away. He's normally good but lately he's been really into my chicks. Plus after we fucked these two girls together a few weekends ago he's really into that now. I'm thinking I'll have to get back to there's for it to work.

Anyway, thanks for the advice. I think if I play it cool and act nonchalant everything will go well.