I was the fat awkward weird kid throughout middleschool and slowly changed to how I am know, senior year, 6'3 6 pack and getting big but my game is pretty bad, I've heard form some people that I come off I guess "creepy"? Am I coming in too hot? My group and I party every weekend but they've been with this one girl consistently and she doesn't want me tagging along because I "creep" her out? I don't really understand why, also, when it comes to rando girls at the beach etc. I can always introduce myself and catch their interest at first but simply don't know what to say or have ideas, I dry out of ideas. The thing that's bothering me the most is that I'm supposedly a creep and have no idea why...?

Focus on your body language and facial expressions. See and test how you smile in front of the mirror. You might be surprised. I thought my smile was pleasing, but then I tested it in front of a mirror and it was not what I expected it to be. Never look at her breasts. That might also be a reason why you creep women out.

If you're concerned about what to say then learn the basics of small talk, so you won't go interview-style and ask yes-no questions.