Quote:
" got a 97 on a paper, and a number from a really cute girl, not bad for a monday"
would that be too giving her too much value too fast?
It's not really the value thing that is wrong here, it's more that 1) your compliment is not specific and 2) it makes you look like you never get numbers from cute girls and you're not used to this kind of attention. You need to act like cute girls give you their numbers all the time and it's not a surprise when it happens. But you also want Girl A to feel special, like she is better than the other girls. She probably gets called cute by every other guy, so you're not showing you're different from the other chumps by calling her cute. This doesn't mean you shouldn't be clear with your intentions and interest in her, but try to be more original when you give her a compliment.
Unless the girls are super-nerdy in class, going back to opener is kind of stale, you want to show that there is more to you than just getting the 97 on the paper, unless you want to keep up the 97 Club angle as a form of bonding, but there are better ways of building rapport.
Of course, this is assuming Girl A is of a legal age of consent. Otherwise just keep making out until she's legal.
.