Met this cute girl on POF 6 weeks ago, we've been dating and hanging out. She's conservative and same religion I am so it took a few weeks and 5 meetings later but we recently started kissing and making out 2 nights ago then she left to go to a party. She use to text me everday and we flirt a lot over text. She texted me at the party about how she smells like me (after making out) and loves it but then the texts stopped.

However I recently saw her the day after party and she opened up to me about how she felt. She said she got a text from this guy she was talking to months ago while at the party and it brought up old feelings ect but continued to say that she could never date him and he's ugly but really funny and stuff implying I'm not. She thinks I'm really hot and her friend called me Tom Brady ect.

The kicker is she proceeded to say she's just not sure of her feelings and she likes me but not completely sure 100%. She says she feels forced to like me since we met on a dating website and she wishes we had mutual friends. She then said she doesn't want to be boyfriend and girlfriend yet ect.. I told her I felt the same and asked her what kinda guys she's into (bad boys). We cooked dinner and then she hugged me for 5 minutes, made out and then I left. Haven't heard from her since.
It's been a day. Can this be recovered? How should I have reacted when she told me her feelings (liking me but not in a relationship type way)?

My sticking point is that I can come off funny and cocky in texts but can't play it well with girls I just met. I'm naturally shy and reserved but confident most of the time.

How do I tackle this?