Your problem seems pretty clear to me:
Quote:
HB: Blah blah
You're not listening and/or not interested in what she has to say!
Quote:
Let's take an easy example. Suppose a girl said to you "At this party last night, I got really drunk and started grinding with my girlfriend and making out with her."
Possible topics for you to vibe off of are:
1. The party last night
2. Parties in general
3. What you did last night
4. Getting really drunk
5. Girls making out with other girls
6. Her girlfriend
7. Grinding/dancing
8. Dancing at parties/clubs
This is the easy part. Just by recognizing what a wealth of topics she presents you with every time she opens her mouth, you'll solve the problem of "stalling out" and having nothing to say.
Do you ever run out of things to say with your buddies? I'm guessing no; because you're relaxed and interested in what they have to say. Take some interest, qualify her and challenge her and stop concentrating on the outcome.