I read mystery method and the game, but have only put it to use in field a handful of times. I actually just signed up to post this, hoping I could get some good advice. What do you guys think?

So last night was my 21st birthday. I went out with 8 friends to a bar in lower Manhattan around 9:30 to celebrate the occasion. After an hour of my friends buying me shots left and right and having our side of the bar being the life of the party, a girl who had been talking to one of my friends bought me a shot of whiskey and pickle juice (a strange combination, but actually was pretty good..) At first, I thought she had come with my friend, but I learned she was actually alone, which I started teasing her about. Over the course of 15 minutes, we talked about our parents and how we have adopted their behaviors and habits, told her she was attractive, but what really matters is personality, and gave her a personality test. She was into me, but as usual, I found it hard breaking through and escalating kino. The more we talked, the mare antsy she got, as if she was on a time restraint, but she kept good eye contact and did not mind me grabbing her shoulders or her polk-a-dot scarf thing around her neck.

She wanted to go out for a cigarette, so I said I would join her. We get outside to find two of my friends hanging out with three other girls, a redhead, a blonde, and a girl with a bleached pixie cut - three girls that I saw hanging out inside. I jokingly asked them if they were starting trouble with my friends, telling them I have their back. They all laughed. I introduced them to my knew found friend, the whiskey and pickle juice girl. The talk was cut brief, our train was leaving grand central in 20 minutes, and it was the last one. I ran in to use the bathroom real quick. When I came out, I found the pickle juice girl hanging out and the bar where we were talking before. She wanted me to read some poetry thing she had on her phone, which I actually tried to do, but this was cut short when a friend of mine grabbed my arm telling me we had to go. I told her to take my number because my phone was dead (which it actually was) and kissed her on the cheek goodbye. Then I said fuck it and kissed her on the lips then left ( i feel like i fucked that one up....)

I was just running out the door and heard girls screaming behind me "bye birthday boy!" I turn around and see the three girls from outside sitting at the bar. I run up to them and say "somebody take my number, we all have to hang out again!" One of the girls take it down on her phone, and I finally get out of there.

We all run to grand central and just made the train by a second. We actually had to hold the doors for a little for everyone to catch up haha

I woke up this morning ad get three texts, all within 10 minutes of each other (two within the same minute):

10:36 AM

"hey it's your cigarette buddy! Hope you had a bitchin' birthday!

10:36 AM

"Hey, Ted, it's the REALLY COOL REDHEAD from outside the bar last night. I HOPE YOU HAD THE BEST 21ST BIRTHDAY!!"

10:46 AM

"Hey, it's the blonde girl from the bar last night, hope you had an amazing 21st birthday!

I don't know how to take this from here.. And it was kind of strange they all texted within the same time frame. The most attractive girl was the redhead, an HB8, the blonde was an HB6 and the pixie cut girl was an HB7.

Do I only text one of them? All of them? What do I say?

Hey Ted,

Great job, sounds like you had a fun birthday. On the topic of the three girls, by the sounds of it, it seems like these three girls are competing for you bro. I mean if you think about it, I don't think all three took your number when you said it to them. One of them must have came up with the idea for all three to text you and see which one you choose. Just my opinion.

Personally, I would play along with the situation. It's seems like they the three of them sent you relatively the same texts. Now respond back in the similar fashion.

I don't know if you remember a show where there would be a guy/girl and three contestant behind a screen. The guy/girl would ask the three contestants questions and based off only the answers, would decide who he/she will go on a date with them.

Try and do that with these girls and see what happens. Something along the lines "Hey blonde/bleached pixie dust/redhead, didn't get a chance to talk to you girls for very long. The three of you seem like an interesting group. Just thinking, if you got a chance to take me out alone, where would you take me?"
send it individually to the them.

Touch up the wording on that, but I would definitely play it along those lines...whatever you decide to do, just have fun with it.

Hope that helps,

samex

Hey Samex,

Thanks for the reply, I love your take on the whole thing. Seems like the best way to have fun while using the situation to its fullest.

It's been 12 hours since I received the texts, and I just sent out what you had suggested to the three of them within 3 minutes of each other:

--
"Hey Ms. Blonde!

Wasn't given much of a chance to talk to you girls last night. You seem like an interesting group. Just thinking, if you had the chance to take me out alone, where would you take me? "
--

Basically this text x3. They were each almost the same text, but slightly different wording.

Ms. Blonde was actually the first to reply - 18 minutes later:

--
"This feels like a gameshow question.
I don't know, probably a bar or something. Which is a boring answer. Haha"
--

Considering it's 2:19AM, I have some time to sit on this. This would be the first time I've ever played text game. I guess I'm aiming to be light and funny/cocky? That was certainly the vibe that was going the night we all met. I feel with Ms. Blonde's last text, she just set herself up.

Your exactly right! Remember this game is under your rules, and its for your entertainment, so play it the way you want to play it.

Like you said "that was certainly the vibe that was going the night we all met", thats why they liked you. Just stay consistent and continue having fun.

samex