I usually wear a nice, but not flashy shirt with long sleeves and a collar. I have a few solid color ones from Express, and a couple others with simple patterns. I have a couple "peacocky" shirts with cool embroidery and multiple fabrics (e.g. inside the collar and front buttons). Kinda like English Laundry but not.
For accessories I have a leather/metal necklace that I usually wear. I usually wear 2 rings and I generally wear my simple watch with 2 bracelets. I do have one "fancy" watch which is made by Todd Bloom, and I love it, except I can only wear it with my "peacocky" shirts or it doesn't go.
I don't bother with flashy belts since my shirt covers it so nobody would ever see it.
For pants I have decent but simple jeans (also from Express) that fit well, or I will wear some distressed grey/black/brownish corduroy ones I have (kinda hard to describe). Those are really a bit too distressed and will probably be retired soon.
As for shoes, I have a few pair of black leather in different styles. Decent but not fancy. I really need to get some nicer ones.
So that's pretty much my wardrobe.
Oh and depending how I think the night will go I will wear red boxer shorts!

_________________
--
For Dallas-area PUAs, check out the Dallas Lair at
http://www.dallaslair.org