I've had multiple girls recommend Armani code by armani, aqua di geo by armani and fierce by abercrombie and fitch.
I use them now exclusively and have great success with them. Stylish girls often get quite excited about the fierce because its both great smelling and throws a light on the fact that you do sometimes go in for a bit of fashion, making the girl feel fashionable because she can recognise it. For example I wore it recently in new york when i was meeting a sexy french club promoter at my house. 2 girls commented on how good I smelt, then she got very proud and excited and said "I know what it is..." showing off. I made fun of her a little bit playfully for showing off then later during the party I actually lifted her up on top of me and carried her to my bed, closed the door and threw her on to it.
people saw us go and she didn't care. Just a little extra detail probably not because of the cologne but its still fun to brag.
the armani code always gets me comments but people don't always recognise it like the fierce. likewise with aqua di geo but girls love it.
I'm an armani man through and through