This technique is excellent and it definitely works but does anyone else think this is kind of wrong? Let me illustrate the irony of this.. so say you've used this technique, gamed her and made her think of all her boyfriend's shortcomings. Now they're arguing a lot, and they after a while they break up. You close the deal and a month later you're in a relationship with her. You REALLY like her, you know she's a real catch. Now I come along, and I use the straw man technique. You have no idea this is going on, as a high value male you do not have insecurities or trust issues so you don't feel the need to check up on your girl.
Now, unless you are some kind of perfect, infallible being incapable of making any mistakes or having any shortcomings, there are going to be flaws in the relationship that this technique will unwittingly highlight to her. Before you know it, she's resenting you for leaving your boxers on the floor again, or not cuddling after sex.
How would you feel if this happened to you? The list of reasons the OP gives are rationalizations to sidestep the guilt of doing something like this.
Sorry to put a downer on the topic like this, but being a human being comes first and pick up comes second for me.
It's not a magic trick dude. It doesn't bypass rational human thought and feeling. This will work on girls who are in unsatisfactory relationships, which, unfortunately, is probably the majority. If you are a genuinely a high value male, she'll be unlikely to cheat no matter what someone says to her. Don't overvalue the tricks of the trade, man, being a real person comes first.